"We need a pen test" is one of the most common things we hear, and often it is not quite what the business needs first. Penetration tests, vulnerability scans and Cyber Essentials answer different questions. This guide explains each one, what it costs, and how to decide.
The short version
| What it answers | Who does it | Typical cadence | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vulnerability scan | Which known weaknesses are visible right now? | Automated tool, ideally reviewed by a person | Continuously or monthly |
| Cyber Essentials | Are the five basic controls in place? | Self-assessment, checked by a certification body | Every year |
| Cyber Essentials Plus | Are those controls really working on our machines? | Independent technical audit | Every year |
| Penetration test | Could an attacker actually get in, and how far? | Skilled testers, manually | Yearly, or after major changes |
Vulnerability scanning
A vulnerability scanner checks your systems against a database of known issues: missing patches, outdated software, weak configurations, exposed services. It is fast, cheap and repeatable, which makes it the right tool for finding the obvious problems continuously.
Its limits: it only finds what it already knows about, it produces false positives, and it does not tell you how weaknesses combine. A scan saying "medium risk" on three separate findings will not tell you that together they let someone reach your finance system.
Cyber Essentials and Cyber Essentials Plus
Cyber Essentials is the UK government-backed scheme that the NCSC describes as the minimum standard of cyber security it recommends. It covers five technical controls:
- Firewalls
- Secure configuration
- Security update management
- User access control
- Malware protection
The basic certification is a self-assessment questionnaire, verified by a certification body. The current requirements are version 3.3, in force since 27 April 2026; among other changes, cloud services can no longer be excluded from scope.
IASME, which runs the scheme, publishes the fees for basic Cyber Essentials (as of October 2026, plus VAT):
| Organisation size | Employees | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| Micro | 0–9 | £320 |
| Small | 10–49 | £440 |
| Medium | 50–249 | £500 |
| Large | 250+ | £600 |
Cyber Essentials Plus adds an independent technical audit. It is not a penetration test. The assessor scans your external IP addresses, checks a representative sample of devices (supported software, high and critical patches applied within 14 days, malware protection) and watches users carry out everyday tasks. It has to be done within three months of the basic certificate. There is no fixed price: certification bodies quote based on the size and complexity of your network.
When Cyber Essentials is required
Since 24 February 2025, Procurement Policy Note 014 sets out when central government departments, their agencies, non-departmental public bodies and NHS bodies require Cyber Essentials or Cyber Essentials Plus. It applies to higher-risk contracts, such as those that handle citizens' or staff personal data, involve ICT systems at OFFICIAL, or support core government business and finance. Certificates must be renewed every year.
Even outside government work, larger customers increasingly ask suppliers for it. For most small businesses, it is the best first step: it is cheap, it fixes the basics, and it is something you can show.
Penetration testing
A penetration test is a controlled attempt to breach your systems the way a real attacker would, carried out by people rather than a tool. Testers chain small weaknesses together, test logic flaws a scanner cannot understand, and show you what an attacker could actually reach.
The NCSC's guidance makes an important point: a penetration test is a way of gaining assurance, not your primary way of finding vulnerabilities. It compares a pen test to a financial audit: it checks that your own processes for finding and fixing vulnerabilities are working. If you have never scanned or patched systematically, a pen test will mostly tell you things a scan would have found for far less money.
Scoping a pen test well
Following the NCSC's guidance, a good scope:
- involves the people who own the risk, your technical staff and the testers;
- shares your existing vulnerability information with the testers, so they spend time on what you do not already know;
- states the boundaries, the types of testing, the timeframe and effort in days, and what the report must contain.
A good report gives each finding a risk rating and a recommended fix, and an opinion on how well your own vulnerability management is working. Deciding what to fix, and in what order, stays with you; a good tester will help you prioritise.
For central government and critical national infrastructure, the NCSC runs the CHECK scheme for approved penetration testing companies. Other organisations are free to choose their testers, so ask for sample reports, methodology and the experience of the people who will actually do the work.
So which first?
- You have never looked at security formally: start with Cyber Essentials. It fixes the basics and is often required anyway.
- You hold Cyber Essentials and want proof the controls work: Cyber Essentials Plus.
- You run your own applications, store sensitive data, or have a customer or insurer asking for assurance: a scoped penetration test, alongside regular vulnerability scanning.
- You have changed something significant (a new application, a new office network, a move to the cloud): test that change.
How we help
Sothware runs security audits and penetration tests for applications and infrastructure, scoped around what you actually need assurance on, with a plain-English, prioritised plan to fix what we find and a re-test to confirm the fixes. If you are not sure which of the above you need, ask us and we will tell you honestly.